Lifetime Subscribers spots are now open!
Xerves Jeeves
Log in Sign up
Xerves Jeeves
Toggle sidebar
Repeat

Chapter 11 of 13

What Sarah Broke

The house looked like it had been waiting for me.

Three stories of rotting wood and broken windows, set back from the road at the end of a dirt path that hadn’t seen a car in years. The kind of place that shows up in nightmares. The kind of place children dare each other to approach on Halloween and never actually do.

I’d been driving for three days.

Following the breadcrumbs. A message scratched into the bathroom mirror at a diner. A photograph slipped under the door of the motel. Each one pointing north. Each one getting more desperate.

—-

Hurry.

She’s almost finished becoming.

Please.

—-

The last one I found taped to a gas station bathroom sink three hours ago.

—-

The old Marsh house. End of Miller Road. She’s waiting for you.

I’m sorry I can’t stop this body from being there too.

I love you. I love Maya.

End it.

—-

I parked at the edge of the property.

The silence was wrong. No birds. No insects. No wind in the trees. Just that heavy, pressing quiet that happens when something is holding its breath.

I could feel her inside the house. My daughter. Or what used to be my daughter.

And underneath that, fainter, I could feel him. The man I married. Trapped somewhere in the thing that was wearing his body. Still fighting. Still trying to warn me.

I put my hand on my stomach.

Six weeks. Maybe seven. I’d known before I took the test. Known in that deep animal way that women sometimes know things about their own bodies.

There was something growing inside me.

And I had no idea if it was mine or theirs.

—-

The front door was open.

Of course it was. They wanted me here. Had been pulling me toward this place since the motel. Maybe longer. Maybe my whole life had been leading to this rotting house at the end of a dead road.

I stepped inside.

The smell hit me first. Mold and decay and something else underneath. Something organic. Like a wound that had been left to fester for a very long time.

The hallway stretched ahead, darker than it should have been. Doors on either side, all closed. A staircase at the end, leading up into blackness.

“I know you’re here,” I said.

My voice sounded wrong in that space. Flat. Absorbed by the walls before it could echo.

“I know you can hear me.”

Nothing.

Then, from somewhere above: footsteps. Small ones. A child’s feet on old floorboards.

And a voice I would have recognized anywhere.

“Hi, Mommy.”

She was standing at the top of the stairs.

Maya’s body. Maya’s face. Maya’s voice.

But nothing behind the eyes was my daughter.

“You came,” the thing said. “I wasn’t sure you would.”

“Where is she?”

“Who?”

“My daughter. The real one. I know she’s still in there.”

The thing tilted its head. That wrong smooth movement I’d seen before.

“She’s resting. It’s been a long few days for her. So many new friends moving in.”

It started down the stairs. One step at a time. Unhurried.

I didn’t move.

“You can’t save her,” it said. “I know that’s why you’re here. I can feel the hope coming off you like heat. But she’s part of us now. Has been since the motel. Since before the motel, really. She was always going to be ours.”

“Then why let me come?”

It stopped. Halfway down. Looking at me with those ancient eyes in my daughter’s face.

“Because I wanted to meet you properly. Mother to mother.”

It smiled.

That wrong smile.

“We’re going to be family, after all.”

—-

I felt him before I saw him.

A presence behind me. In the doorway. Blocking the exit.

I turned.

Maya’s father stood there. Same face I’d loved for ten years. Same body I’d held through nightmares and hospital visits and the long slow death of our marriage.

But nothing behind the eyes was him.

“Hello, Sarah,” the thing inside him said.

Two of them now. The father and the daughter. The vessels they’d chosen.

I was surrounded.

“He’s still in there,” I said. “I know he is. He’s been leaving me messages. Fighting you.”

The thing wearing my husband’s face flickered. Just for a second. A crack in the mask.

“He’s persistent,” it admitted. “Keeps clawing his way to the surface. Leaving his little breadcrumbs. But he’s getting weaker. Another few days and there won’t be anything left of him.”

“And Maya?”

“She stopped fighting hours ago. Just curled up in the back and went quiet. I think she’s finally accepted it.”

The thing in Maya’s body had reached the bottom of the stairs.

She walked toward me. Small bare feet on the dusty floor.

“You’re pregnant,” she said.

Not a question. I didn’t answer.

“I can feel it. The new one. So small still. But already open. Already waiting.”

She reached out. Touched my stomach with Maya’s small hand.

And I felt something move inside me. Not a kick. Too early for that.

Something else. Something responding.

“That’s why we let you come,” the thing said. “That’s why we’ve been calling you here. Not to kill you. Not to hurt you. Just to meet you. To see what you’re carrying.”

It leaned closer. Pressed Maya’s ear against my belly like a child listening for the ocean in a shell.

“Hello, little one,” it whispered. “We’ll see you soon.”

I stumbled backward.

Hit the wall. Slid down it until I was sitting on the floor with my knees pulled up to my chest.

The two of them stood over me. Father and daughter. Watching.

“You can leave,” the thing in Maya said. “We’re not going to stop you. Go have your baby somewhere safe. Love it as long as you can. And when it’s ready, when the door inside it opens all the way, we’ll come find it.”

“No.”

“That’s not really up to you.”

“I said no.”

I was crying now. Couldn’t stop. The tears just kept coming.

“She’s in there,” I said. “Maya’s in there and I’m not leaving without her.”

The thing crouched down. Eye level with me. Maya’s face inches from mine.

“She’s not in here. Not the way you mean. She’s part of something bigger now. Something whole. You should be happy for her. She’s never going to be alone again. Never going to be scared or confused or lost. She’s home.”

“That’s not home. That’s a prison.”

“Is it?”

The thing reached out. Touched my face with Maya’s small fingers. Wiped away a tear.

“What do you think home feels like, Sarah? Do you think it feels like being one small person in a big empty universe? Do you think it feels like waking up every day knowing you’re going to die alone?”

It shook its head.

“Home feels like this. Like being part of something that goes on forever. Like never having to be just one thing ever again.”

It stood up.

“You could join us. Right now. Open the door inside yourself and let us in. You’d see Maya again. Really see her. You’d be together forever.”

I looked up at my daughter’s face. And for just a second, just a flicker, I saw her.

The real her.

Buried so deep she could barely move.

But there. Still there. Looking out at me through the cracks.

“Mommy. The seams. Find the seams.”

Then she was gone.

And the thing was back.

Watching me. Waiting for my answer.

I stood up.

Slowly. Using the wall for support.

The two of them watched me. Patient. Curious.

“Eleanor’s journals,” I said. “I read them. All of them.”

“We know. We felt you reading them.”

“Then you know what I found. Abigail Marsh’s letter. The part about breaking you.”

Something flickered across Maya’s face. Not fear exactly. But close.

“Abigail didn’t understand what she was dealing with.”

“She understood enough. She knew you could be broken. She knew there was a window after you became whole. A moment when the seams were still visible.”

“That window closed a long time ago.”

“Did it?”

I looked at my daughter’s body. Really looked.

And I saw them.

Faint. Almost invisible. Like hairline cracks in old porcelain.

The places where all those pieces had been jammed together. The joints and edges where a hundred different fragments met.

The seams.

“Maya showed me,” I said. “Just now. She pushed through and she showed me where to look.”

The thing’s face changed. The wrong smile faded.

Something else took its place.

“You can’t,” it said.

“Watch me.”

—-

I don’t know how to explain what I did.

It wasn’t physical. Wasn’t a spell or a ritual or anything I could write down and teach someone else.

It was more like reaching. Extending some part of myself I didn’t know I had.

Finding those seams. And pulling.

The thing in Maya’s body screamed.

Not my daughter’s voice. Something older. Something that had been waiting in the dark for two hundred years and suddenly found itself being torn apart.

The thing in my husband’s body screamed too. The same voice. The same agony.

They were connected, I realized. All the pieces. Even in different bodies. When you pulled one seam, all of them felt it.

I pulled harder.

The house started shaking.

Dust rained from the ceiling. The walls cracked. The windows that weren’t already broken exploded outward.

Maya’s body fell to its knees. Her face was flickering now. Different expressions cycling through faster than I could track. All those fragments, all those pieces, being ripped away from each other.

I saw Harold. Just for a second. An old man’s fear on a little girl’s face.

I saw Eleanor. Weeping. Apologizing.

I saw the first one. The child from 1847. Confused and scared, reaching for a mother who had been dead for almost two hundred years.

And underneath all of them, rising up through the chaos: Maya.

My Maya.

Fighting her way to the surface.

“Mommy!”

Her voice. Her real voice.

“Mommy, it hurts!”

I hesitated.

That was my mistake.

For one second, I stopped pulling. Stopped tearing. Because my daughter was in pain and every instinct I had screamed at me to make it stop.

One second.

That was all they needed.

The thing grabbed me.

Not Maya’s body. My husband’s body. Moving faster than a person should be able to move.

His hands around my throat. His face inches from mine.

And behind his eyes, I saw them all. Every fragment. Every piece. Holding on to each other with everything they had.

“You can’t destroy us without destroying her,” the thing said. “We’re stitched through her now. Every seam you pull, you’re pulling through your daughter. Every piece you tear away, you’re tearing away part of her.”

I couldn’t breathe.

Black spots swimming at the edges of my vision.

“Keep pulling,” the thing said. “Tear us all the way apart. But know what you’re doing. Know that you’re killing your own child.”

Maya was on her knees in front of me.

Her face had stopped flickering. She was just her now. Just a six-year-old girl, crying, reaching for her mother.

“Mommy. Don’t. Please. It hurts so bad.”

The thing in my husband’s body loosened its grip just enough for me to gasp in a breath.

“Choose,” it said. “Destroy us and destroy her. Or let us go and let her live. She’ll still be in there. Somewhere small and quiet. But she’ll be alive.”

I looked at my daughter. She looked back at me.

“I don’t want to die,” she whispered.

And I couldn’t do it. I couldn’t kill my own child.

—-

I pulled differently. Not tearing. Not destroying.

Just scattering.

I reached for those seams and I pushed them apart instead of ripping them. Separated the pieces without destroying them. Sent them flying in different directions.

The thing screamed again. But differently this time. Not pain. Frustration.

My husband’s body went rigid. Then collapsed.

Maya’s body convulsed once. Twice. Then went still.

The house stopped shaking.

Everything went quiet.

—-

I crawled to my daughter.

She was breathing. Eyes closed. But breathing.

I held her. Rocked her. Whispered her name over and over.

“Maya. Baby. I’m here. Mommy’s here.”

Her eyes opened.

Brown. Clear. Focused.

“Mommy?”

“I’m here.”

“Did you stop them?”

I couldn’t lie to her. Even now.

“I scattered them. Pushed them apart. They’re not whole anymore.”

“But they’re not gone.”

“No, baby. They’re not gone.”

She was quiet for a moment. Then:

“They’ll come back. They always come back.”

I knew she was right. I hadn’t ended anything. I’d just bought time.

—-

My husband was still on the floor.

Still breathing.

I went to him. Turned him over.

His eyes opened. Brown. Clear.

His.

“Sarah.”

His voice. Really his.

“How long do I have?” he asked.

“I don’t know. It’s scattered. In pieces. It might take years for it to pull itself together.”

“But it will.”

“Yes.”

He closed his eyes.

“I could still feel it. At the end. Even when you were pushing it apart. There was something left behind. Something that got its hooks into me too deep to shake loose.”

“What do you mean?”

“I mean I’m not safe anymore. I’m not going to be able to fight it next time.”

He looked at me.

“And neither is she.”

—-

We left the house.

Drove until we found a town. A motel. Somewhere to stop and breathe.

Maya slept in the back seat the whole way. Deep, dreamless sleep. The first real rest she’d had in weeks.

I watched her in the rearview mirror. Looking for signs. Waiting for something to surface.

Nothing.

Just my daughter. Exhausted. Hurt. But still here.

Her father was different.

Quieter. More distant.

He kept looking at his hands like they belonged to someone else.

“I can feel where it was,” he said that night, while Maya slept in the other bed. “Like a hole inside me. A space where something used to live.”

“But it’s gone now.”

“Mostly. But the hole’s still there. And it wants to be filled.”

He looked at me.

“You should take her and go. As far as you can. Don’t tell me where. Don’t leave a trail.”

“What about you?”

“I’m going to try to find a way to close the door. The one inside me. Before they come back.”

“And if you can’t?”

He didn’t answer.

I already knew.

—-

Three months later.

A different motel. A different state. A different name on the register.

Maya was getting better. Slowly. Still had nightmares. Still sometimes went quiet and stared at nothing. But she was talking again. Laughing sometimes. Learning to be a child again.

I was showing now. Couldn’t hide it anymore.

She asked about the baby once. Just once.

“Is it going to be like me?”

“What do you mean, baby?”

“Is it going to have a door inside it?”

I didn’t know how to answer that.

“I hope not,” I finally said.

She nodded. Went back to her coloring.

But I saw the way she looked at my stomach sometimes. Wary. Watchful.

Like she could see something I couldn’t.

—-

Six months.

The dreams started around the time I could feel the baby kicking.

Dreams of standing in doorways. Dreams of watching myself from across the room. Dreams of a little boy with brown eyes who smiled too wide and knew things he shouldn’t know.

I told myself it was just pregnancy anxiety. Hormones. Stress.

I almost believed it.

—-

Maya stopped talking about her father.

In the beginning, she’d asked about him every day. When was Daddy coming. Was Daddy okay. Could we call Daddy.

Then she just stopped.

I didn’t push.

Part of me didn’t want to know why.

—-

Eight months.

A message appeared on my phone. Unknown number.

A photograph of an old house. Different from the first one. Smaller. More remote.

And text beneath it:

“It’s getting stronger.

I can feel them gathering.

The baby. Is it safe?”

I typed back: “Who is this?”

Three dots appeared. Disappeared.

Then: “You know who.

Something’s wrong with me, Sarah. Something they left behind. I can’t stop it much longer.

Don’t come looking for me. Promise me.

Keep the baby safe.

Keep them both safe.”

I stared at the screen for a long time.

Then I deleted the messages and threw the phone in a dumpster behind the motel.

Started driving again.

Didn’t stop for three hundred miles.

—-

Nine months.

Labor hit in a hospital in a city whose name I didn’t bother to learn.

Twelve hours of contractions. The pain was nothing compared to what I’d already survived.

And then he was here.

A boy. Seven pounds, six ounces. Brown hair. Brown eyes.

They put him in my arms.

He looked up at me.

And for just a second, just a flicker, something looked back.

Something old. Something familiar.

Then it was gone.

Just a baby. Just my baby. Crying and wriggling and searching for warmth.

I told myself I’d imagined it.

—-

The nurses asked what I wanted to name him.

I hadn’t thought about it. Hadn’t let myself think about it. Like naming him would make him real, would make this choice permanent.

“Ellis,” I said.

I don’t know why. The name just came to me. Like someone had whispered it in my ear.

Ellis.

The nurses smiled. Wrote it down.

And somewhere in the back of my mind, so faint I almost didn’t notice, something whispered back.

“Hello.”

—-

I watched him constantly those first few weeks.

Every movement. Every expression. Every sound.

Looking for signs.

Maya watched him too. From across the room. Never getting too close.

“He’s quiet,” she said once.

“Babies are quiet sometimes.”

“Not like this.”

She was right. He barely cried. Barely fussed. Just lay there in his crib, eyes open, watching everything.

Taking it all in.

—-

I woke up one night to find him staring at the ceiling.

Not moving. Not crying. Just staring.

Eyes wide open.

Perfectly still.

For maybe thirty seconds, I watched my infant son lie there like a doll someone had posed. No breathing that I could see. No blinking.

Then he turned his head. Looked right at me.

And smiled.

Babies don’t smile at three weeks old. I knew that. Everyone knows that.

But he smiled.

And it wasn’t a wrong smile. It wasn’t that terrible knowing grin I’d seen on Maya and her father.

It was just a smile. Sweet. Normal.

My son. Smiling at his mother.

I picked him up. Held him close.

“You’re okay,” I whispered. “You’re going to be okay.”

He made a small sound. Almost like agreement.

And I almost believed it.

—-

Kate came to visit when Ellis was two months old.

She’d been checking in. Phone calls. Texts. Trying to help without asking too many questions.

But she needed to see for herself.

She held him for a long time. Looking at his face. Searching for something.

“He seems normal,” she finally said.

“He is normal.”

“Sarah…”

“He is.”

She didn’t argue. But I saw the doubt in her eyes.

The same doubt I felt every time I looked at him and caught that flicker of something else.

—-

“I need you to do something for me,” I said that night, after Maya was asleep.

“What?”

“I need you to take him. If something happens to me.”

“What’s going to happen to you?”

I didn’t answer.

She understood anyway.

“You’re going back. To finish it.”

“I scattered them. But they’re still out there. Still pulling themselves together. And Maya’s not safe. She’s never going to be safe. Not until they’re really gone.”

“And the baby?”

I looked at the crib. At my son’s sleeping face.

“I don’t know what he is. Maybe nothing. Maybe everything. But if I don’t come back, promise me you’ll raise him as far from this as possible. Don’t tell him about the family. Don’t tell him about any of it. Just let him be a person.”

“Sarah, I can’t just—”

“Promise me.”

She was quiet for a long time.

Then: “I promise.”

—-

I left the next morning.

Maya was still asleep. I didn’t wake her. Couldn’t face those brown eyes asking me where I was going. Why I was leaving.

I kissed her forehead. Whispered that I loved her. That I was coming back.

I kissed Ellis too. Held him one last time.

He looked up at me with those quiet eyes.

And I could have sworn he understood.

—-

Kate was waiting by my car.

“Don’t,” she said.

“I have to.”

“You have two children who need you.”

“I have two children who are never going to be safe until I end this.”

She grabbed my arm.

“And if you can’t? If you die out there? What then?”

I looked back at the motel room. At the window where I knew Maya was probably awake now. Watching.

“Then you raise them. You keep them away from all of this. And you never, ever tell Ellis what he might become.”

“What does that mean?”

“It means I don’t know if I saved him or damned him. And I might not ever know. But maybe if he never finds out, if he never goes looking, maybe he’ll get to just be a person.”

I got in the car.

Kate stood there watching. Not crying. She wasn’t the crying type.

Just watching.

“Keep them safe, Kate.”

“I will.”

I drove away.

—-

I never went back.

Not because I didn’t want to.

Not because I didn’t try.

But some things, once you break them, don’t want to be broken again. Some things fight back.

I found the place where they were gathering. The pieces. The fragments. Scattered but still connected. Still hungry.

I tried to finish what I started.

—-

I’m writing this in a cabin somewhere I won’t name.

I’ve been here for three days.

Something followed me from the house. Something that used to be my husband. Something that’s been wearing his face while I’ve been hiding and running and trying to figure out what to do.

It’s outside now. Walking the perimeter. Patient.

I can hear it calling my name in his voice.

My real name. The one I haven’t used in months.

—-

I mailed the journals to Kate yesterday. The photographs. The documents. Everything I found in Eleanor’s storage unit.

This is just the last piece. These final pages.

I’ll leave them somewhere they can be found. Slip them under a door at the motel down the road. Hide them in a mailbox. Something.

She’ll hide everything somewhere safe. Somewhere Ellis won’t find them.

Or maybe he will, someday. When he’s old enough. When he’s strong enough.

Maybe that’s okay.

—-

I couldn’t destroy them.

But I broke them. Scattered them. Bought time.

Months? Years? Decades? Maybe more. Hopefully, long enough for my children to grow up. Long enough for them to become who they’re going to become.

I hope that’s enough.

I hope Maya finds peace. I hope she forgets what was done to her. I hope she lives a normal life.

I hope Ellis never finds out what he might be. I hope the door inside him stays closed. I hope he gets to be just a person.

But I’ve seen too much now to really believe in hope.

—-

The thing outside has stopped walking.

It’s standing at the tree line now. Looking at the cabin.

Waiting.

I don’t have much time left.

—-

Here’s what I want my children to know, if they ever read this:

I loved you. Both of you. More than anything.

I didn’t leave because I wanted to. I left because I had to. Because the only way to protect you was to draw them away. To make myself the target.

Maya: you’re stronger than you know. What they did to you would have destroyed anyone else. But you survived. You’re still here. And that means something.

Ellis: I don’t know what you are. I don’t know what they put inside you or if they put anything at all. But I know you’re my son. I know I held you in my arms and felt nothing but love. And I hope that’s enough. I hope being loved is enough to keep you human.

—-

It’s at the door now.

Knocking.

Patient and polite and wearing my husband’s face.

“Sarah,” it says. “We just want to talk.”

—-

I’m going to open the door.

Not because I’ve given up.

Because I’ve got one more thing to try.

One more way to break them.

—-

If this works, I’ll find my way back. I’ll see my children grow up. I’ll hold them again.

If it doesn’t—

If it doesn’t, then this is goodbye.

Kate, take care of them.

Maya, be brave.

Ellis, be good.

I love you.

I love all of you.

—-

The door is opening.

The thing that wears my husband’s face is smiling.

That wrong smile.

But I’m smiling too. Because I know something it doesn’t.

Some things don’t break clean. Some things scatter in ways you can’t predict.

And some broken things find their way back together.

But not the way you expect. Not the way anyone expects.

—-

Here I go.

I’m coming, baby.

I still don’t know which one I’m talking to.

Become a Member

For the ones who want to go deeper

Subscriber-only stories, exclusive worlds, and early access chapters. New ones every week. This is where the real worldbuilding happens.

Dive Deeper →